This Mystery is out of date! Please proceed to Fates of Traits to see the updated version.
Can selection happen without people?

Can selection happen without people?

Lesson narration:
Scroll for prep

Predict 1 of 2: What do you think might have happened to the green anoles, once the brown anoles arrived in Florida and started to get hungry?




Predict 2 of 2: Not all of the green anoles are exactly the same. Which green anoles do you think the brown anoles are most likely to catch?

#Want to know more about how scientists study lizards?
# Extensions
Below are ideas for extending this topic beyond the activity & exploration which you just completed.
# Natural Selection Simulation

To show that selection can happen without people, play the Peppered Moth game. Here’s how:

  • Open the link. Click on and read “how to play” aloud. At the start of the game, half the moths are light-colored and half are dark.
  • Click “play game.” Choose to hunt for moths among trees with pale bark or trees with dark bark. Before choosing, ask students whether they think the color of the tree’s bark will make any difference to the moth population.
  • Make your choice. Suddenly, you’re a hungry bird, pecking at moths. In the upper left corner, you’ll see a timer and a count of how many moths you’ve eaten. Down below, you’ll see graphs that show how you have affected the moth population.
  • When the game ends, make a note of how the moth population changed. Then play again. This time choose the other type of forest. Once again, at the start, half the moths are light colored and half are dark. Note the results of the game.
  • Discuss as a class: How would you explain these results?
Slide Image
Slide Image

species


1 of 11

one specific kind of living thing that has similar characteristics and can produce offspring with one another

predator


2 of 11

an animal that hunts and eats other animals

survive


3 of 11

to stay alive
Slide Image

trait


4 of 11

something you can observe about a living thing, such as the number of toe scales of a lizard
Slide Image

inherited trait


5 of 11

a trait of a living thing that comes from its parents

natural selection


6 of 11

a process where certain traits help a living thing survive, so those traits are more likely to be passed to the next generation of offspring
Slide Image

variation


7 of 11

the different versions of a trait, such as the number of toe scales of a lizard

adaptation


8 of 11

a trait that helps a living thing survive in its environment
Slide Image

population


9 of 11

how many there are of a particular type of living thing
Slide Image

generation


10 of 11

all the living things born and living at around the same time
Slide Image

graph


11 of 11

an image that helps you understand information

Image & Video Credits

Mystery Science respects the intellectual property rights of the owners of visual assets. We make every effort to use images and videos under appropriate licenses from the owner or by reaching out to the owner to get explicit permission. If you are the owner of a visual and believe we are using it without permission, please contact us—we will reply promptly and make things right.

Exploration
Anole on rocks by JamieS93 , used under CC BY-SA
2 Anoles by numbers by Seadevil
tropical island by Christopher Michel , used under CC BY
brown geko by Michel Pierfitte , used under CC BY-SA
catching Anoles by Adam Algar
green geko by Tambako the Jaguar , used under CC BY-ND
white geko by Nick Hobgood , used under CC BY
Tokay climbing wall by Tokay Gecko
holding small Anole by txbowen , used under CC BY
green lizard with long tail by Melissa Gutierrez , used under CC BY-SA
Anole on log by Paul Hirst , used under CC BY-SA
lizard holding branch by L Church , used under CC BY
Cuban Anole by Thomas Brown , used under CC BY
cargo boat by Gerolf Drebes , used under CC BY-SA
large green lizard by Euku , used under CC BY-SA
fishermen by Anole Annals Blog
lizard on flowers by www.GlynLowe.com , used under CC BY-ND
Anole on pipe by Daniel Ramirez , used under CC BY

Featured Reviews

“Oh my gosh! This was such a fun, engaging activity. It really made it easy for the students to understand selection.”
“I love the ease of teaching Science with these lessons!! The students love it!”
“THIS WAS AWESOME!!! All of my students really understood this and were able to write about what happened on Lizard Island. It was such a great hands on activity so they could see it visually!”
“The students were very engaged in the lesson. They are beginning to understand how the process of selection creates variance in species!”
“Students were engaged, followed along, and lesson was used for a class with special needs!”
“Students were able to model the process of natural selection and will be able to make connections between this and their learning of adaptations and how animals adapt to their environment.”
“Students loved them! I love how it incorporates Math (graphing) as well. Great lesson and super engaging :)”
“It went very well, the students had a great understanding of the selection process and were able to accurately predict the results.”
“The class really enjoyed getting to "adopt" lizards and got a kick of getting "eaten." Very engaging and brought about some great discussions!”
“Just as good as the rest of your lessons.....to the point...easy to understand at all levels.....well organized and interactive, authentic activities that excite the kids! ”
“This was an outstanding way for my kids to really grasp the concept of natural selection. They enjoyed it!”
“The reading about the scientists. Students demonstrated their understanding through detailed illustrations, and the definitely got the main concepts. ”
“Terrific way to learn about natural selection. Well planned lesson. I did this lesson with 1 child using the printed notes and it worked perfectly. My 7 year old loved working out which babies would be able to climb.”
“Easy to follow and great discussion questions. Fun for the class. Taught the content really clearly! (I used it with 6th grade science and it was a really simple, fun way to experience natural selection and survival of the fittest!)”
“Lizard Island is always our favorite!! It is such a good lesson to teach selection. Students are completely engaged!”
“The kids loved playing the game where they got to "adopt a lizard". They were really able to tell how selection works by watching it in action with the role playing.”
“The activity was awesome, they loved it! A different way for them to put in practice what they learned.”
“My students loved the fact that they were carrying out an activity that real scientists had also done!”
“Kids loved the game with Lizard Island. Love the step by step instructions :) Thank you for such a great resource!!!”
“I loved that this got the students up and moving. It was great that it included some cooperative learning and the students really grasped the concept of genetics!!”
“My kids were very engaged (just like all your lessons!) Some of them could relate to it because they've seen anoles when visiting Florida, and they liked the interaction of the activity. My coworker did the activity before you guys improved it and said that it didn't go well. I'm pleased to announce that it went very well with my class. Thank you for taking people's inputs seriously and adjusting lessons according to our needs. We love Mystery Science!”
“Students were engaged! The children want to learn more about the scientists from Lizard Island. They also began inquiry into how this concept plays out with fish in the ocean and animals on land. ”
“The lizard activity was really eye-opening and engaging. It made the concept more realistic for learners so they could apply the knowledge to the real world. Thanks!”
“I thought it was very ingenious how you planned the tracking of the lizards but breaking the class into groups etc. They loved it!”
“The improvements to this lesson are fantastic! I have taught both and this one made more sense not only to my kids, but to a teacher who was sitting in as well! Keep up the great work MysteryScience! I love your work! ”
“I love the visual explanation behind natural selection!!!”
“They LOVED figuring out if the babies were excellent climbers or not!”
“The kids really got into the selection process. It is as exciting for me as a teacher as it was for the kids.”
“The students enjoyed the fact that they had different lizards from each other. They also liked the counting off by number to determine which lizards did not survive. They appreciated that even though their lizard did not make it, they would still be involved and given another lizard. It was fun and we all learned a lot.”
“I love that the lesson was broken into sections where the kids could work in groups, and then listen to the video, then back and forth. They really enjoyed the extended info on the scientists.”
“The kids loved the graphics, especially seeing the Geico gecko and the emoji type faces when the lizards were eaten. I loved the math concepts that were included, and the real life applications. They were very successful in understanding how selection occurred naturally.”
Lesson narration:

Activity Prep

Print Prep
In this lesson, students learn about an example of how nature, not human beings, can slowly change the appearance of an animal using the process of selection. In the activity, Lizard Island, students simulate how natural selection affects a group of tree-climbing green lizards when their island is invaded by hungry brown lizards. This simulation only works for groups of 16 or more students. If you have a smaller group, use the Small Group Version of this activity found in Prep Instructions.
Preview activity

Exploration

10 mins

Wrap-Up

5 mins

Extend this lesson

Vocabulary

Reading

Activity

Online Simulation

Download this Lesson to your device so you can play it offline:
 
Selection Lesson 3: Can selection happen without people?

How did the lesson go?
Terrible OK Good Great Terrific!

How can we improve it?

If you'd like our team to reply to you, please Contact Support instead.

Thanks for your feedback! If you have a question or need help, please contact us. Please consider sharing your review:

Sorry the lesson didn’t go well. We read every single review in an effort to improve our Mysteries.

Thanks for letting us know. We’ll wait to ask you for feedback until after you've actually taught it.

Thanks for the feedback! We read every single review in an effort to improve our Mysteries.

Is the video not playing properly?

Please follow these steps:

  1. Very rarely a video will fail to completely load in your browser. Try to reload this page to see if that fixes the problem.
  2. If reloading does not help, try our other video player .
  3. If the video still fails to play, open this video in a new tab

Close

How can we help you?

💡For purchasing info, see our Pricing Page

This episode is locked

This lesson is not included in your limited access.

View pricing

This episode is locked

Your membership is expired. The archive of past Mini Lessons is not included in your limited access.

View pricing